Discussion Question Category: Metaphysics

Stellaluna

WHAT MAKES A . . . Duck a duck? Cat a cat? Man a man? Woman a woman? Parent a parent? Car a car? Bird a bird? Smile a smile? Feeling a feeling? Thought a thought? WHAT DOES A THING NEED TO. . . What does a kite need to fly? What does a tree Stellaluna

Runaway Bunny

IS SOMETHING STILL ITSELF IF IT CHANGES? Is a chair still a chair if its legs are broken? Is a song still a song if everyone forgets the words? Is a spoon still a spoon if it falls behind the stove and is never seen again? Is a book still a book if some pages Runaway Bunny

Press Here

Did what we did affect the book? How do we know what’s going to happen? How do we know when one event causes another event? Was the book magic? Contributed by Gobe Hirata

Penguin Story

Why is Edna unsatisfied that she can only see three colors (white, black and blue)? Are there unknown things that you wish to see and learn about, just like Edna? What are they? What are the most important things to know? If Edna had only ever seen three colors, then how could she know that Penguin Story

On the Verandah

When you are reading a really good book, do you sometimes feel like your mind is transported to the land of the story? If your body remains in the same time and place, where are you really? Is a mind the same thing as a brain, or are they different? What kinds of things are On the Verandah

Obstinate Pen

Where do thoughts come from? Do we always do what we intend? What is the relationship between what we intend and our actions? Do we have control over our thoughts? Over our actions? What is the mind? What kinds of things have minds? Can a pen have a mind? A table? A plant? An ant? Obstinate Pen

Morris the Moose

Why does Morris believe that the cow is a moose? Does Morris have good reasons for believing this? Does the cow have good reasons for insisting she is not a moose? What are these reasons? When the animals see their reflections in the stream, what makes them conclude that they are not the same after Morris the Moose

Magic

What does a fortune teller claim to know? How could she know that? Do you think we could know what the future holds? If so, how? If not, why not? Would it be easier to predict the immediate future, or the distant future? Why? Is human behavior more difficult to predict than other behavior (maybe Magic