Discussion Question Category: Epistemology

You Are Stardust

What is nature? Are we a part of nature or are we outside of it? What is our relationship to the rest of the natural world? Are we connected or disconnected? If we are connected, or a part of, the natural world, what implications does this have on the way we treat it? Do we You Are Stardust

On The Day You Were Born

Option 1: Read the story only and then have a discussion. If questions come up about science background, you can refer to the index or other info sources. This option is the most open-ended and may lead to a discussion that is more generally philosophical and less scientific in nature. Option 2: Read the story. On The Day You Were Born

Why?

Why ask why? What is the purpose of a question? Why do we ask questions? What makes a question a good one? Is curiosity a good thing? Why do you think Lily’s father sometimes became annoyed with Lily when she asked “Why?” Could a question really save the world? Could it destroy it? Can asking Why?

Where the Wild Things Are

Max experiences the fantastical forest and monsters as if they are real. Does that mean that the forest and monsters are real? How do you know whether something is real or imagined? How do you know whether or not you are dreaming right now? Is it possible for time to go by without anything changing? Where the Wild Things Are

Sylvester and the Magic Pebble

WHAT IS MAGIC? Is magic real? What kinds of things are magic? Imagination and Existence Can anything you imagine really exist? If you had a magic pebble like the one Sylvester found what would you do with it? What would you wish for? What other ways could you get your wish? Do you think the Sylvester and the Magic Pebble

Penguin Story

Why is Edna unsatisfied that she can only see three colors (white, black and blue)? Are there unknown things that you wish to see and learn about, just like Edna? What are they? What are the most important things to know? If Edna had only ever seen three colors, then how could she know that Penguin Story

Obstinate Pen

Where do thoughts come from? Do we always do what we intend? What is the relationship between what we intend and our actions? Do we have control over our thoughts? Over our actions? What is the mind? What kinds of things have minds? Can a pen have a mind? A table? A plant? An ant? Obstinate Pen

Morris the Moose

Why does Morris believe that the cow is a moose? Does Morris have good reasons for believing this? Does the cow have good reasons for insisting she is not a moose? What are these reasons? When the animals see their reflections in the stream, what makes them conclude that they are not the same after Morris the Moose